• About
  • Grievance Redressal cell
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • Our team
  • Survey
Thursday, February 9, 2023
  • Login
  • Home
  • Insider Exclusive
    ‘I will head party till elections to be held on  5’: Dr. Farooq Abdullah

    ‘I will head party till elections to be held on 5’: Dr. Farooq Abdullah

    ‘My source of inspiration is Atal Bihari Vajpayee

    ‘My source of inspiration is Atal Bihari Vajpayee

    BJP to form next Govt in J&K of its own: Raina     

    BJP to form next Govt in J&K of its own: Raina     

    BJP creates history for declaring holiday on Maharaja’s birth anniversary: Raina

    BJP creates history for declaring holiday on Maharaja’s birth anniversary: Raina

    Our non-participation in contesting Panchayati elections was a big mistake’: Dr Farooq

    Our non-participation in contesting Panchayati elections was a big mistake’: Dr Farooq

    Veteran leader Ghulam Nabi Azad resigns from Congress party.

    Veteran leader Ghulam Nabi Azad resigns from Congress party.

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Jammu and Kashmir
  • Entertainment
    Kiara Advani And Sidharth Malhotra Share Wedding Pics: “Now We Are Permanently Booked”

    Kiara Advani And Sidharth Malhotra Share Wedding Pics: “Now We Are Permanently Booked”

    Pathaan Box Office Collection Day 6: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film Set To Be Fastest To Make 300 Crore

    Pathaan Box Office Collection Day 6: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film Set To Be Fastest To Make 300 Crore

    Pathaan Box Office Collection Day 3: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film Earns Over ₹ 300 Crore Worldwide

    Pathaan Box Office Collection Day 3: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film Earns Over ₹ 300 Crore Worldwide

    Kangana Ranaut takes sly dig at fans praising Shah Rukh Khan’s Pathaan: ‘Goonjega toh yahan sirf Jai Shri Ram’

    Kangana Ranaut takes sly dig at fans praising Shah Rukh Khan’s Pathaan: ‘Goonjega toh yahan sirf Jai Shri Ram’

    Pathaan Sets A Record Even Before Release: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film To Open In Over 100 Countries

    Pathaan Sets A Record Even Before Release: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film To Open In Over 100 Countries

    “The Way I Dress…”: Uorfi Javed Struggles To Find Rented Apartment In Mumbai

    “The Way I Dress…”: Uorfi Javed Struggles To Find Rented Apartment In Mumbai

  • Articles
    Prophet Muhammad (SAW), His Life & Teachings

    Prophet Muhammad (SAW), His Life & Teachings

    Crime against women unacceptable: Dr. Navneet Kaur.

    Crime against women unacceptable: Dr. Navneet Kaur.

    Monkeypox Spreading By Sexual Contact Between Men, Not By Skin Contact.

    Monkeypox Spreading By Sexual Contact Between Men, Not By Skin Contact.

    Jodhpur violence: What United Nations spokesperson said on clashes before Eid

    Jodhpur violence: What United Nations spokesperson said on clashes before Eid

    ‘My father was gullible, I am shrewd’: Uddhav Thackeray’s message to BJP, MNS

    ‘My father was gullible, I am shrewd’: Uddhav Thackeray’s message to BJP, MNS

    The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild gameplay on the Nintendo Switch

  • National
  • Our team
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Insider Exclusive
    ‘I will head party till elections to be held on  5’: Dr. Farooq Abdullah

    ‘I will head party till elections to be held on 5’: Dr. Farooq Abdullah

    ‘My source of inspiration is Atal Bihari Vajpayee

    ‘My source of inspiration is Atal Bihari Vajpayee

    BJP to form next Govt in J&K of its own: Raina     

    BJP to form next Govt in J&K of its own: Raina     

    BJP creates history for declaring holiday on Maharaja’s birth anniversary: Raina

    BJP creates history for declaring holiday on Maharaja’s birth anniversary: Raina

    Our non-participation in contesting Panchayati elections was a big mistake’: Dr Farooq

    Our non-participation in contesting Panchayati elections was a big mistake’: Dr Farooq

    Veteran leader Ghulam Nabi Azad resigns from Congress party.

    Veteran leader Ghulam Nabi Azad resigns from Congress party.

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Jammu and Kashmir
  • Entertainment
    Kiara Advani And Sidharth Malhotra Share Wedding Pics: “Now We Are Permanently Booked”

    Kiara Advani And Sidharth Malhotra Share Wedding Pics: “Now We Are Permanently Booked”

    Pathaan Box Office Collection Day 6: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film Set To Be Fastest To Make 300 Crore

    Pathaan Box Office Collection Day 6: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film Set To Be Fastest To Make 300 Crore

    Pathaan Box Office Collection Day 3: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film Earns Over ₹ 300 Crore Worldwide

    Pathaan Box Office Collection Day 3: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film Earns Over ₹ 300 Crore Worldwide

    Kangana Ranaut takes sly dig at fans praising Shah Rukh Khan’s Pathaan: ‘Goonjega toh yahan sirf Jai Shri Ram’

    Kangana Ranaut takes sly dig at fans praising Shah Rukh Khan’s Pathaan: ‘Goonjega toh yahan sirf Jai Shri Ram’

    Pathaan Sets A Record Even Before Release: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film To Open In Over 100 Countries

    Pathaan Sets A Record Even Before Release: Shah Rukh Khan’s Film To Open In Over 100 Countries

    “The Way I Dress…”: Uorfi Javed Struggles To Find Rented Apartment In Mumbai

    “The Way I Dress…”: Uorfi Javed Struggles To Find Rented Apartment In Mumbai

  • Articles
    Prophet Muhammad (SAW), His Life & Teachings

    Prophet Muhammad (SAW), His Life & Teachings

    Crime against women unacceptable: Dr. Navneet Kaur.

    Crime against women unacceptable: Dr. Navneet Kaur.

    Monkeypox Spreading By Sexual Contact Between Men, Not By Skin Contact.

    Monkeypox Spreading By Sexual Contact Between Men, Not By Skin Contact.

    Jodhpur violence: What United Nations spokesperson said on clashes before Eid

    Jodhpur violence: What United Nations spokesperson said on clashes before Eid

    ‘My father was gullible, I am shrewd’: Uddhav Thackeray’s message to BJP, MNS

    ‘My father was gullible, I am shrewd’: Uddhav Thackeray’s message to BJP, MNS

    The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild gameplay on the Nintendo Switch

  • National
  • Our team
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home National

RTI is not applicable to collegium’s consultation, discussion: Supreme Court

The apex court dismissed a petition demanding information about a 2018 collegium meeting under the right to information (RTI) act

News Insider's Desk by News Insider's Desk
December 9, 2022
in National
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A
0
0
SHARES
2
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Only a resolution drawn and signed by all the judges in the collegium can be said to be the final decision of the collegium, the Supreme Court declared on Friday as it dismissed a petition demanding information about a 2018 collegium meeting under the right to information (RTI) act.

“The collegium is a multimember body whose decision is in the form of a resolution. Until a resolution is drawn and signed by all the members of the collegium, it cannot be said to be a final decision. Whatever is arrived at during the process of consultation, it can at best be said to be a tentative decision,” held a bench of justices MR Shah and CT Ravikumar.

It added that the content of the discussion does not require to come out in the public domain and therefore, the provisions of the RTI Act shall not be applicable to such consultation.

“Only the final decision requires to be uploaded,” said the court, refusing to entertain the petition by RTI activist Anjali Bhardwaj.

Also Read: Collegium system law of the land, comments against it not well taken: Supreme Court

In her plea, Bhardwaj had cited statements and press reports quoting former Supreme Court judge Madan B Lokur according to which the collegium resolution was not uploaded on the SC website despite a decision taken at the meeting on December 12, 2018, to elevate justice Pradeep Nandrajog, the then chief justice of the Rajasthan high court, and justice Rajendra Menon, the then chief Justice of the Delhi high court, as judges to the top court.

According to reports, Justice Lokur, who retired on December 30, 2018, and reportedly took part in the collegium meeting that approved the names of the two high court chief justices, said he was “disappointed” that the decision taken by the collegium on December 12, 2018, was not “followed and put out.”

While hearing the petition on December 2, the bench called itself the “most transparent institution”, adding the collegium system should not be derailed on the basis of statements of “some busybody.”

It further disapproved of adverse comments made by its former judges against the selection mechanism of the collegium, terming it a “fashion”.

Refusing to pay heed to the petitioner’s emphasis on justice Lokur’s statements, it said on that day, “We don’t want to comment on anything said by former members. Nowadays, it has become a fashion for the former members to comment upon the decision when they were part of the collegium.”

Bhardwaj had approached the Supreme Court against the denial of information to her by the top court’s administration regarding the agenda and other pertinent information about the December 2018 collegium meeting. Her appeals before the central information commission (CIC) and the Delhi high court also failed to elicit any positive response.

The Delhi high court, meanwhile affirming the decision of the public information officer of the SC administration earlier this year, held that in the absence of any formal resolution being adopted and signed by the members of the SC collegium for the said meeting, the authorities rightly took the position that there was no material liable to be disclosed. Further, it said that “unsubstantiated and unverified” press reports cannot be taken cognisance of.

Lately, the union government and the Supreme Court seems to be at loggerheads over the collegium system of appointing judges.

While various functionaries such as Vice President Jagdeep Dhankar and union law minister Kiren Rijiju have adversely commented on the system of selecting judges for constitutional courts, a Supreme Court bench has repeatedly pulled up the government over delays in clearing appointments, clarifying the collegium system is the law of the land which the executive is bound to follow.

News Insider's Desk
Previous Post

Supreme Court junks plea on regulating religious processions: ‘All not source of riots’

Next Post

Canada adds sanctions on Russia, Iran, Myanmar over human rights

News Insider's Desk

News Insider's Desk

Next Post
Canada adds sanctions on Russia, Iran, Myanmar over human rights

Canada adds sanctions on Russia, Iran, Myanmar over human rights

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest

Demolition of Shopping Complex in Anantnag: Div Com Kashmir appointed as inquiry officer

July 12, 2022
IAS officer shares his class 10 marksheet on students’ demand, it goes viral.

IAS officer shares his class 10 marksheet on students’ demand, it goes viral.

July 24, 2022
Batal cloud burst: 10 Yatris die, over 40 missing

Amarnath Cloudburst: DHSK cancels leaves of all staff

July 9, 2022

J&K Schools, Colleges, Hospitals to be named after those who laid lives for country’s integrity: LG Manoj Sinha

July 12, 2022

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild gameplay on the Nintendo Switch

0

Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun Review

0

macOS Sierra review: Mac users get a modest update this year

0

Hands on: Samsung Galaxy A5 2017 review

0
Abrogation of Article 370 gave shape to ideology of one-nation: Rana

Abrogation of Article 370 gave shape to ideology of one-nation: Rana

February 7, 2023
Man Accidentally Paid Rs. 66,000 For Burger; Still Waiting For Refund After A Month

Man Accidentally Paid Rs. 66,000 For Burger; Still Waiting For Refund After A Month

February 7, 2023
2 Indian Air Force Planes Land In Earthquake-Hit Turkey With Medical Teams

2 Indian Air Force Planes Land In Earthquake-Hit Turkey With Medical Teams

February 7, 2023
Adani Enterprises Stocks Fall By Over 30%, Hitting Multiple Trading Stops

Adani Ports To Repay $605 Million Debt, Capital Expenditure To Halve

February 7, 2023

Recent News

Abrogation of Article 370 gave shape to ideology of one-nation: Rana

Abrogation of Article 370 gave shape to ideology of one-nation: Rana

February 7, 2023
Man Accidentally Paid Rs. 66,000 For Burger; Still Waiting For Refund After A Month

Man Accidentally Paid Rs. 66,000 For Burger; Still Waiting For Refund After A Month

February 7, 2023
2 Indian Air Force Planes Land In Earthquake-Hit Turkey With Medical Teams

2 Indian Air Force Planes Land In Earthquake-Hit Turkey With Medical Teams

February 7, 2023
Adani Enterprises Stocks Fall By Over 30%, Hitting Multiple Trading Stops

Adani Ports To Repay $605 Million Debt, Capital Expenditure To Halve

February 7, 2023
News Insider

News Insider is news, current affairs and media analysis organization. We value independence and transparency and believe the two are integral to democracy and a healthy society. The same applies for news media, which is often referred to as the fourth pillar of democracy.

Follow Us

Categories

Recent News

Abrogation of Article 370 gave shape to ideology of one-nation: Rana

Abrogation of Article 370 gave shape to ideology of one-nation: Rana

February 7, 2023
Man Accidentally Paid Rs. 66,000 For Burger; Still Waiting For Refund After A Month

Man Accidentally Paid Rs. 66,000 For Burger; Still Waiting For Refund After A Month

February 7, 2023
  • About
  • Grievance Redressal cell
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • Our team
  • Survey

News Insider 24x7 © 2022. All Rights reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Insider Exclusive
  • Jammu and Kashmir
  • Articles
  • National
  • Our Team

News Insider 24x7 © 2022. All Rights reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In